This article was published in freefincal.com, on March 22, 2018, under the “Fee-only adviser journey”. Here is the link to the article.
On January 03, 2019, one more of my articles “Becoming a competent & effective financial advisor: My journey so far” was published in freefincal.com. Here is the link to the article.
“Past events always look less random than they were. I would listen to someone’s discussion of his own past realising that much of what he was saying was just a backfit explanation concocted ex post by his deluded mind.” writes Nassim Taleb in the preface of his book Fooled by Randomness.
While temptation is always there to present a better-looking picture of your own past (based on your memory of the past which is slightly different from what you experienced in reality), I have tried to tell my story like it is.
I have no formal education in personal finance and investing. I accidentally landed in this profession, which luckily suited me. What follows is majorly the story of how I learned personal finance starting as an insurance agent.
I am a Chemical Technologist by education. I worked with Marico Ltd. and Hindustan Unilever Ltd. as a production executive for 3 years. In 2011, I left the job to do something of my own and started a business. Business did not work as expected and I had to close it within a year. This left me in debt and with no cash flow.
In mid-2012, when I had nothing else to do, I applied for LIC agency on a friend’s suggestion. I wanted a temporary source of income until I find something worthwhile to do. But things changed during 10 days of mandatory training before IRDA exam. I heard stories of successful insurance agents and huge income they earn. Incidentally, one of India’s Biggest Insurance Agents Bharat Parekh has an office in the same building I attended this training in. This changed my perception of the profession of insurance selling, and I decided to take it seriously.
I received my LIC licence in Aug 2012. I began attending agent trainings, purchased LIC agent software, and spent days studying plans and plan combinations. Like all naïve LIC agents, I also believed that there is no better investment option than LIC.
At around the same time, someone suggested me that if anyway I am selling insurance, why sell products of one company when it is possible to sell any insurance company’s product through insurance brokers like Bajaj Capital. So I empanelled with Bajaj Capital in September 2012 and began selling all types of insurances through them. In health insurance, I used to sell Apollo Munich and Max Bupa policies.
Company fixed deposits could also be sold through Bajaj Capital, but I never sold them. Quite a few company fixed deposits sold by Bajaj Capital like Plethico Pharma, Elder Pharma, Bilcare, Unitech, Jaiprakash Associates, Omnitech, Micro Technologies have defaulted. I was lucky not to have touched them.
I also took Oriental agency specifically to sell ‘Oriental Happy Family Floater’. This product used to beat all other health insurance products in premium, especially if older members of the family were covered in a family floater policy. There was flaw in the design of this product, and oriental subsequently corrected it.
Barring few close friends, I did not approach friends, relatives and acquaintances to sell insurance since it was embarrassing for me to be seen selling insurance after leaving a good job at HUL. I acquired almost all my early clients through cold calling and subsequent clients through references. I have not asked for references myself from any of my clients all these years. I am too proud to do that (not sure if it is a virtue or vice).
This is a terrible way to sell insurance. My commission in those early days would not even cover EMI of the personal loans I had taken for my sister’s marriage and renovation of our ancestral house.
One fine day I stumbled upon Jagoinvestor.com and it opened the real world of personal finance for me. I learned about the inferiority of traditional insurance products for the first time on Jagoinvestor. I also discovered subramoney.com in one of reader comments there.
Subramoney was a treasure trove of personal finance wisdom. It was addictive. For next few days, I was reading Subramoney leaving everything else. It transformed me from an average insurance agent to a decent adviser within a few days. I have been a regular reader of Subramoney since I discovered it in 2013. (I read all Subramoney articles published from 2008 to 2011 last year. I wanted to see what Subramoney had to say when the 2008 market crash was happening. I started with the first article published in 2008 and kept reading subsequent articles. By the time I stopped, I had reached the end of 2011.)
I became a Mutual Fund distributor in mid-2013. I was a regular reader of Jagoinvestor.com during this period. There was this man Ashalanshu all over Jagoinvestor that time. He used to comment on almost every query. In older comments, there was one Ashal Jauhari commenting in a similar style. In the second half of 2013, Ashalanshu’s activity went down on Jagoinvestor. When I asked him about it in one of my comments, he replied that he is busy with his own Facebook group. I asked if I could join his group and he added me to Asan Ideas for Wealth(AIFW).
AIFW in those days was amazing. I had already discovered freefincal.com by then and was using freefincal calculators. Pattabiraman Murari of freefincal.com was active on AIFW and so was P.V. Subramanyam of subramoney.com. Some quality DIY (Do It Yourself) investors and many well established financial advisers were equally active on the group. My reading and learning of personal finance and investing had already picked up speed by the time I landed on AIFW. But it was mostly through books and blogs. AIFW added the much-needed human element to it.
My participation in AIFW discussions was devoid of political correctness. It irked few people but also attracted attention of right kind of people like Pattabiraman Murari and Ashal Jauhari (I was less aware of my ignorance that time and therefore would post, comment and take part in discussions more often).
Sometime at the end of 2013, Pattabiraman Murari shared with me Canada-based financial adviser Jim Otar’s book “Unveiling the retirement myth”. This book has influenced the way I look at financial planning more than anything else. I learned to look at financial planning in terms of lucky and unlucky outcomes because of this book. It also made me aware of the sequence of return risk, which is one of the most important factors in financial planning.
I discovered Nassim Taleb on Subramoney. Since I did not have spare money to buy books in those days, my reading was restricted to free e-books I could download from internet (all my income would go towards loan EMIs and paying off debt I had incurred because of my failed business). Fortunately, all Taleb’s books were available free on the internet.
Reading Taleb was like getting training in inference. Taleb made me sceptical of all self-proclaimed experts (investing is all about the future and those we consider expert are as clueless about the future as we are). He made me doubt the quality of my own knowledge too. I began understanding the role luck plays in investment performance. My understanding of risk also became better with Taleb.
Reading, studying, and exploring personal finance and investing had become the principal activity of my life by this time. Subramoney.com has a list of 57 must read investment books. I have all these books in my personal library of over 100 investment and related books. I have read most of these books, partially read some and reread few many times. Reading a book or blog is like entering a room. It opens doors to other rooms. I have the habit of opening every door I see and checking the adjacent room. Poor Charlie’s Almanack is one room I never tire of spending time in. Charlie Munger’s approach of “trying to be consistently not stupid instead of trying to be very intelligent” better suits my temperament. This is also the way I like to handle financial planning.
Twitter has also been a great source of learning for me. Whenever I discover some quality handle like @contrarianEPS, I usually read all the past tweets, check other handles it follows and add good handles to different lists I maintain on twitter. Twitter has also become my primary source of news since I do not read newspapers and watch TV.
In my early days in this profession, I wanted to do CFP (Certified Financial Planner) but cost of CFP was too high for me that time. By the time I came in a position to afford it, I had already explored quite a bit of personal finance. I had also seen many advisers flaunting their CFPs whose understanding of personal finance I was not impressed with. If CFP and other such certifications (textbook learning to pass exams) were not going to make me a better adviser, then acquiring them only for image building to attract more business was unethical. (SEBI RIA is one more decoration that tells nothing about the competence of an adviser.)
I stopped selling LIC policies shortly after landing on AIFW which led to the termination of my LIC agency. I also transferred my health insurance business to one senior health insurance agent in Nagpur who deals only in health insurance. I did not have experience of handling claims and my clients could be better served by this agent. I also wanted to get out of insurance completely because mutual fund would excite me more than insurance. This gave me more time to explore personal finance and investing.
I was a member of AIFW when SEBI came up with RIA (Registered Investment Advisor) regulation in 2013. There used to be animated discussions in AIFW about this regulation that time. Initially, I was on the side of adviser community ridiculing Fee Only model but slowly I realised that this is far superior model from the point of view of investors.
This was my message to Pattabiraman Murari dated March 11, 2014, by which time, I had begun thinking seriously about moving to the fee only model. Since I did not have post graduate degree in finance, I needed to fulfil 5-year minimum experience criteria to apply for RIA registration which was still three and half years away. I used this time to build my competence as a financial adviser.
This was also the time when I began staying away from IFA (Independent Financial Adviser) community. Most IFAs have the tendency to think in terms of Mutual Fund AUM, size of SIP book, number of clients and commission. Rarely have I seen an IFA who works as much on sharpening his knowledge of investing as he does on increasing his income. This is an obvious outcome of a system that appreciates and pays to do more not better.
Prospects of earning a higher income somehow doesn’t excite me (This has something to do with my constitution I guess. I wanted to join Ramakrishna Mission when I was in college and even when I was doing the job). I had no appetite for doing 3-5 client/prospect meetings every day either (I am lazy when it comes to doing non-intellectual work). I also have an inability to offer my clients one option when I am aware of a better option available for them. I struggled not talking about direct plans of mutual funds for a long time and stopped putting my clients’ money in regular plans even before becoming an RIA. I was a misfit in the IFA community where nobody believed in fee only model. My reclusion from IFA community helped me keep my thinking clean and maintain my conviction in fee only model.
I do not want to take the moral high ground here for my decision to move to fee only model because it was a rational decision for me to take. AUM gathering (selling) was a game I had little aptitude for and even if I had tried, I could not have become a top IFA; but I can definitely make a name for myself as an RIA. I am only playing a game where I have better aptitude than majority of others. (I do not think in these exact terms. What I want to convey is that I have sacrificed nothing to move to the fee only model.)
In mid-2016, one of my clients asked me to recommend a few good stocks for his stock portfolio. I was not comfortable doing this, but when he kept insisting, I asked him couple of month’s time to do the study. For the next three months, I explored direct equity, leaving everything else. I kept doing the same for three more months after giving my recommendations. In early 2017, I had to take the responsibility of the stock portfolio of one more of my clients against my will. Once again, I found myself spending all my time doing direct equity research. I was also handling my brother-in-law’s stock portfolio during this time and equity portion of my personal portfolio was also totally invested in stocks. Being a bull market, all these portfolios did well. This consumed over 80% of my time for close to a year. Though I earned nothing for all this work, it further increased my understanding of equity as an asset class.
My father had helped me close my personal loans and part of the other debt from his retirement proceeds at the end of 2015 but I still had some money to be returned to a couple of my close friends. In the second half of 2017, I sold my stock portfolio to clear all my debt and to construct my office at home. After selling my own stock portfolio, I noticed that I had lost the intensity with which I was doing stock research earlier. I was also about to submit my application for RIA registration, and I knew that I will not get enough time to do justice to the stock advice. I did not think that I have knowledge, competence and experience enough to advise on stocks either.
So I liquidated the stock portfolio of my brother-in-law I was handling. My first direct equity client had already sold his portfolio for his house construction. I approached the other client and told him that I can no longer take responsibility of his stock portfolio. I suggested him to sell his stock portfolio and invest the amount in mutual fund or take advice of some competent adviser who can take responsibility of his stock portfolio. This got him angry, but he did as suggested. He was in good profit and since I had not charged him anything, there was no obligation on my part.
I cleared mandatory exams for SEBI RIA registration in Feb-2017 and applied for registration after my 5-year minimum experience criteria was fulfilled in Aug 2017. I got my registration on Oct 31, 2017.
I had not yet received my registration when I attended the first meeting of Fee Only India (FOI) in Sept 2017. A month before this meeting, I had spent a day with Melvin Joseph of finvin.in when he had come to Nagpur to deliver a guest lecture in an MBA college. Melvin Joseph was the first man I met from adviser community I felt completely at ease with. I have always found it difficult to speak my mind with most people in this profession. Either they find me over smart or impractical (some call me plain stupid). With Melvin Joseph I didn’t have to dilute my talk. He was also willing to share everything with advisers ready to work on the clean fee only model.
I had a similar experience with other members of FOI. It feels like a family in FOI. Ashal Jauhari and Pattabiraman Murari are like binding force for the group. I also cherish the privilege of discussing difficult financial planning cases with Ashal Jauhari and intellectual stuff with Pattabiraman Murari.
This is one profession where experience counts. I have tried to compensate my lack of experience by spending the majority of my time studying and exploring personal finance and investing in last 5 and half years but I only had as much time. There are still many things I need to learn to fluency as a financial adviser. I have also realised that I cannot become expert at everything.
My wife resigned from her job (as we had decided) the very next day I got my registration and got relieved from the job in the second week of Dec 17. She was working as a teacher in one private school in Nagpur. We are a two-member team now.
It is a popular opinion within adviser community that fee only model doesn’t work in India but this model better suits my temperament and it is working fine for me.
You can also read my article “Becoming a competent & effective financial advisor: My journey so far” published in freefincal.com on January 03, 2019. Here is the link to the article.